A few years ago, I was spurred by the book Good Calories, Bad Calories to worry less about fat and to cut down on some of my carb excesses. And, in general, I was happy enough with the results, but it hadn’t had a huge impact on my life after the first year or so. (Especially since I stopped packing lunches once I rejoined startup life…)
A few months ago, though, some people on a mailing list that I participate in (including the author of the gnolls.org blog) started sharing their experiences with paleo diets, and in particular a few people reported somewhat remarkable results from cutting down on non-rice grain consumption. The author of that blog recommended the book Perfect Health Diet (and its companion blog), so I gave that a read.
Which was quite interesting. A lot of it meshed nicely with what I’d been trying a few years back: in particular, they agree that many fats are just fine, and that many carbohydrates are bad. A lot of the details differ, however: the Perfect Health folks don’t think that it’s good to avoid all carbohydrates, they focus more on specific ones (non-rice grains, fructose, probably others that I’m forgetting) but not all. (In particular, they don’t have much truck with glycemic index, and prefer white rice to brown rice, claiming that the latter can leach nutrients.) Also, there are some other details: they don’t like a lot of standard vegetable oils (though they’re fine with olive oil), but quite like some less common ones, most notably coconut oil.
Spurred by that, I decided to cut down a bit more on my wheat consumption. (Though I’m certainly not going to give up bread entirely, I like it too much!) Which raised the question: what to do about breakfast, if my previous habit of oatmeal wasn’t recommended? At first, I alternated between eggs and bacon or salmon (if I had time), plain yoghurt and fruit (if I had less time), and reheating leftovers. But then a funny thing happened (which other people had predicted): I found myself feeling a lot less hungry in general in the mornings! Before, I would eat a full breakfast and feel like I wanted to start snacking again at around 11am; these days, though, I’m fine not eating anything until lunch time, and in fact on two days at Defcon I didn’t eat anything until around 2pm and felt great. (Which was convenient, there weren’t great food options and the mediocre ones were crowded.)
Also, I’m finding myself feeling full more often. Which is one of the big points of gnolls.org: your body has a feeling for what nutrients you need, and if you feed it the right stuff, you just won’t feel as hungry. The idea of paying attention to signals your body is sending makes a lot of sense to me; and if those signals mean that I’m not eating as much because I’m not feeling as hungry, I’m willing to take that as a sign that I’m doing something right!
I’m not planning to go all-out paleo—like I said, I like (good) bread too much! But it’s also great to not have to worry about eating breakfast, and to not feel hungry as often, so I do think I’ll stick with these changes, and possibly go further with them than I have been.
Post Revisions:
This post has not been revised since publication.
A couple of years ago I quit eating breakfast on weekdays, and since my breakfast had usually been something like a muffin or scone, it reduced my daily caloric intake by around 400. Like you, I found that I simply didn’t need it; I’ve moved my lunch time up to noon, but I don’t feel like I’m starving until then, and my lunches aren’t any bigger than before. The main effect was that my weight dropped around 15 pounds over the following year (and has stayed there).
I know that skipping breakfast doesn’t work for everyone, but it totally did for me.
(My diet is not otherwise special in any way.)
9/2/2011 @ 6:26 am
I’ve recently moved to eating lentils, spinach, and hard-boiled egg for breakfast. It’s filling, but the carbs from lentils are, to my understanding, the ‘good’ kind.
9/2/2011 @ 6:31 am
I’m very suspicious of any diet book that has “Perfect” in the name!
9/2/2011 @ 6:31 am
Dan: interesting, that’s an experiment I didn’t do! For what it’s worth, I don’t _think_ my weight has dropped, though I weight myself so infrequently that I’m not sure. (The Wii Fit is the only scale in our house.) It kind of feels like some of my stomach fat might have changed into muscle, but I could be wrong.
Darius: Lentils are contested, as far as I can tell. Their glycemic index is low, so some people like them; the perfect health book doesn’t, and my guess would be that mainstream paleo doesn’t since they’re suspicious of food that requires processing beyond cooking, if I understand them correctly.
Jordan: Yeah, you and me both. I didn’t like some of the argument by analogy at the start of it, either. But the book seems to do a relatively job of working with science, at least.
9/2/2011 @ 6:04 pm