You are viewing an old revision of this post, from July 19, 2013 @ 13:46:07. See below for differences between this version and the current revision.

On entering the Musée d’Orsay, you are confronted almost immediately with a sight that is familiar to anybody who plays video games, namely a textbook example of male gaze:

This is Femme piquée par un serpent, by Auguste Clésinger; because, of course, we all know that, when a woman is bitten by a snake, her immediate reaction is to contort her body in a way as to make herself look as stereotypically fuckable as possible. You can see the snake in this view of the statue, which also demonstrates another classic male gaze aspect of the statue, namely the way she twists her body so the viewer can simultaneously get a good view of one of her breasts and her ass. (And we all love the way the snake harkens back to the Garden of Eden mythos, where women are simultaneously patsies and the source of the fall of humanity!) Admittedly, it could be worse: the artist has a rather better grasp on female anatomy than many video game modelers, and I suppose one advantage of nudity in this context is that it makes various clothing fails impossible. Still: not awesome.

This is, fortunately, in stark contrast to the rest of the museum, which is one of my favorite places on the planet. Not a contrast because of the nudity—there’s that everywhere you look in the museum—but much of that nudity is rather more interesting, and for that matter rather more foreign to the video game experience. Lots of straightforward, less problematic nudes; lots of nudes that are more interesting, too. Or more confusing; I still don’t know how to analyze Courbet’s L’Origine du monde, for example:

At least it’s something I don’t get from video games, for better or for worse.

I have rather fewer misgivings about Manet, whose Olympia and Déjeuner sur l’herbe are two of my favorite paintings in the museum:

I’m not entirely comfortable with the politics of either of those paintings, but there’s a lot more going on there than in Clésinger’s statue. And while I’m not going to claim that male gaze considerations are absent here, in both examples the gazes that the women present are fascinating:

Which isn’t to say that I spent all my time in the museum looking at female nudes. Sticking with Manet, we have his portrait of Berthe Morisot au bouquet de violettes, and there are male nudes as well! (The one below being Antonin Mercié’s David.)

Though the most surprising nude of the day was this Académie d’homme âgé nu from a special exhibit of Akseli Gallen-Kallela’s work. (Or Axel Gallén, as he was known at the time that he painted this picture.)

 

Anyways: enough nudes, on to video games. The nudes, of course, remind me of character models in video games, and there are plenty of good non-nude character models in the museum: Corot’s La jeune femme à la robe rose, Amaury-Duval’s Madame de Loynes, Degas’s Petite danseuse de quatorze ans (also known as Grande danseuse habillée), Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer’s La Sorcière. (Certainly that last one would be very much at home in a video game!)

But games don’t just model people, they model buildings, they model spaces, they model everything that appears within them. Here are some models of buildings, both by Monet, namely his Gare Saint-Lazare and Rouen Cathedral:

In that last example, Monet shows the cathedral in various different lighting scenarios, and that sort of dynamic behavior is a very video-gamey thing to do. Some of the building models had an implicit dynamism of a different nature, however; my favorite example of that was Corot’s, Le moulin de Saint-Nicola-lez-Arras:

When looking at this picture, it’s impossible not to imagine yourself standing in the woods in the front, walking through them to the building in the back, walking still further to cross the bridge. This isn’t a static model in a video game, it’s a level that demands exploration. (And, of course, I’m doing this within the Musée d’Orsay, which is itself a space that demands exploration every bit as much as any video game I’ve ever played!)

 

So we’ve moved from models of people to models of buildings to locations to be explored. And, if we combine those, we get paintings with implicit narratives: Henri Regnault’s Exécution sans jugement sous les rois maures de Grenade (which, as a bonus, returns us to our video game theme of politically problematic positioning that we led off with, this time with Orientalism instead of male gaze!); Paul Huet’s Le gouffre, paysage; George Desvaillières’s L’Ascension du Poilu; Gustave Moreau’s Galatée. (Male gaze so strong that our lustful onlooker has three eyes! Male gaze was everywhere in this trip: even the Lion King posters in the subways were full of it.)

I’m sure Roger Travis will say it’s no coincidence that the paintings that I saw that gave me the strongest video game vibe were illustrations from epics: Adolphe William Bouguereau, Dante et Virgile aux Enfers and two Kalevala scenes from the aforementioned Akseli Gallen-Kallela exhibit, namely La Défense du Sampo and La Forgeage du Sampo. That last pair brings us closer to video games in another way: just as games are rarely about a single event, instead presenting a linked chain, here too we have linked scenes.

 

A couple of years ago, I took inspiration from musicals and proposed that narrative video games should present themselves as a sequence of set pieces that are as well-crafted as possible, with just enough connective tissue to let you go from set piece to set piece without being jarring. And my experiences in the Musée d’Orsay gave me a new perspective on that argument: each of those set pieces should have the unity and impact of a painting. There should be a vision, a scene, an interaction at the core of each set piece with the rest unfolding from it.

I’ve been playing Journey recently; it’s a beautiful game, a powerful game, and that power comes in large part from this focus. Imagine a sequence of paintings: your first jump after receiving the scarf, looking up at the broken bridge with a companion, investigating a ruin in a desert, surfing the sand together with your companion through a sequence of gates, going through a blue tunnel and trying to hide from the searchlight of an overhead terror, looking up at a tower to climb, huddling with your companion for warmth against the cold and wind, soaring gloriously through the sky. That’s what each level is, and each level does nothing more than what is necessary to bring life to those visions, ending just as you’re feeling satisfied with that experience. The levels never drag on; energy that might be devoted to extending the levels or connecting the levels more broadly is instead devoted to making each level more beautiful, to make each level speak to something surprisingly deep inside of you. (Not that they neglect the connective tissue between levels: as with the musical example, connection is necessary, and the tapestries do a beautiful job of that.) Scene after scene in that game emanates from a vision that would absolutely not be out of place in my favorite museum in the world.

The converse is not, however, true: there were several pictures in that museum that are showing me something that I’m not yet getting from video games. I’ll close with Millet’s Gleaners and Strindberg’s Vague VII, in hopes that one of these years I’ll encounter games that hit those parts of my soul.

Post Revisions:

Changes:

July 19, 2013 @ 13:46:07Current Revision
Content
Unchanged: On entering the Musée d'Orsay, you are confronted almost immediately with a sight that is familiar to anybody who plays video games, namely a textbook example of male gaze: Unchanged: On entering the Musée d'Orsay, you are confronted almost immediately with a sight that is familiar to anybody who plays video games, namely a textbook example of male gaze:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// publicdomainpictures.wordpress.com/ 2011/04/11/auguste-clesinger- woman-bitten- by-a-snake-femme- piquee-par-un- serpent/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ clesinger-femme- piquee-595x446.jpg" alt="" title="Cl&eacute;singer, Femme piqu&eacute;e par un serpent" width="595" height="446" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6054" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// publicdomainpictures.wordpress.com/ 2011/04/11/auguste-clesinger- woman-bitten- by-a-snake-femme- piquee-par-un- serpent/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ clesinger-femme- piquee-595x446.jpg" alt="" title="Cl&eacute;singer, Femme piqu&eacute;e par un serpent" width="595" height="446" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6054" /></a>
Unchanged: This is Femme piqu&eacute;e par un serpent, by Auguste Cl&eacute;singer; because, of course, we all know that, when a woman is bitten by a snake, her immediate reaction is to contort her body in a way as to make herself look as stereotypically fuckable as possible. You can see the snake in <a href="http:// www.humanite.fr/ culture/gustave- courbet-en-son- pays-ornans- 477889">this view</a> of the statue, which also demonstrates another classic male gaze aspect of the statue, namely the way she twists her body so the viewer can simultaneously get a good view of one of her breasts and her ass. (And we all love the way the snake harkens back to the Garden of Eden mythos, where women are simultaneously patsies and the source of the fall of humanity!) Admittedly, it could be worse: the artist has a rather better grasp on female anatomy than many video game modelers, and I suppose one advantage of nudity in this context is that it makes various clothing fails impossible. Still: not awesome. Unchanged: This is Femme piqu&eacute;e par un serpent, by Auguste Cl&eacute;singer; because, of course, we all know that, when a woman is bitten by a snake, her immediate reaction is to contort her body in a way as to make herself look as stereotypically fuckable as possible. You can see the snake in <a href="http:// www.humanite.fr/ culture/gustave- courbet-en-son- pays-ornans- 477889">this view</a> of the statue, which also demonstrates another classic male gaze aspect of the statue, namely the way she twists her body so the viewer can simultaneously get a good view of one of her breasts and her ass. (And we all love the way the snake harkens back to the Garden of Eden mythos, where women are simultaneously patsies and the source of the fall of humanity!) Admittedly, it could be worse: the artist has a rather better grasp on female anatomy than many video game modelers, and I suppose one advantage of nudity in this context is that it makes various clothing fails impossible. Still: not awesome.
Unchanged: This is, fortunately, in stark contrast to the rest of the museum, which is one of my favorite places on the planet. Not a contrast because of the nudity&mdash;there's that everywhere you look in the museum&mdash;but much of that nudity is rather more interesting, and for that matter rather more foreign to the video game experience. Lots of straightforward, less problematic nudes; lots of nudes that are more interesting, too. Or more confusing; I still don't know how to analyze Courbet's L'Origine du monde, for example: Unchanged: This is, fortunately, in stark contrast to the rest of the museum, which is one of my favorite places on the planet. Not a contrast because of the nudity&mdash;there's that everywhere you look in the museum&mdash;but much of that nudity is rather more interesting, and for that matter rather more foreign to the video game experience. Lots of straightforward, less problematic nudes; lots of nudes that are more interesting, too. Or more confusing; I still don't know how to analyze Courbet's L'Origine du monde, for example:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// artbymasza.blogspot.com/2010/ 05/seks-i-konsumpcjonizm.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ origine-du-monde.jpg" alt="" title="Courbet, L'Origine du monde" width="500" height="429" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6057" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// artbymasza.blogspot.com/2010/ 05/seks-i-konsumpcjonizm.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ origine-du-monde.jpg" alt="" title="Courbet, L'Origine du monde" width="500" height="429" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6057" /></a>
Unchanged: At least it's something I don't get from video games, for better or for worse. Unchanged: At least it's something I don't get from video games, for better or for worse.
Unchanged: I have rather fewer misgivings about Manet, whose Olympia and D&eacute;jeuner sur l'herbe are two of my favorite paintings in the museum: Unchanged: I have rather fewer misgivings about Manet, whose Olympia and D&eacute;jeuner sur l'herbe are two of my favorite paintings in the museum:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.ibiblio.org/wm/paint/ auth/manet/olympia/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ olympia-595x399.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Olympia" width="595" height="399" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6061" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.ibiblio.org/wm/paint/ auth/manet/olympia/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ olympia-595x399.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Olympia" width="595" height="399" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6061" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File: Manet,_Edouard_ -_Le_Déjeuner_ sur_l'Herbe_( The_Picnic)_ (1).jpg"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ dejeuner-sur- lherbe-595x470.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, D&eacute;jeuner sur l&#039;herbe" width="595" height="470" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6062" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File: Manet,_Edouard_ -_Le_Déjeuner_ sur_l'Herbe_( The_Picnic)_ (1).jpg"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ dejeuner-sur- lherbe-595x470.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, D&eacute;jeuner sur l&#039;herbe" width="595" height="470" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6062" /></a>
Unchanged: I'm not entirely comfortable with the politics of either of those paintings, but there's a lot more going on there than in Cl&eacute;singer's statue. And while I'm not going to claim that male gaze considerations are absent here, in both examples the gazes that the women present are fascinating: Unchanged: I'm not entirely comfortable with the politics of either of those paintings, but there's a lot more going on there than in Cl&eacute;singer's statue. And while I'm not going to claim that male gaze considerations are absent here, in both examples the gazes that the women present are fascinating:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// colourfullines.blogspot.com/ 2010/04/two-nudes-in-full- colour.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ olympia-face.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Olympia (detail)" width="224" height="252" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6063" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// colourfullines.blogspot.com/ 2010/04/two-nudes-in-full- colour.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ olympia-face.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Olympia (detail)" width="224" height="252" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6063" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.pileface.com/sollers/ article.php3?id_ article=1168"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ manet-dejeuner-face.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, D&eacute;jeuner sur l’herbe (detail)" width="240" height="306" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6064" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.pileface.com/sollers/ article.php3?id_ article=1168"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ manet-dejeuner-face.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, D&eacute;jeuner sur l’herbe (detail)" width="240" height="306" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6064" /></a>
Unchanged: Which isn't to say that I spent all my time in the museum looking at female nudes. Sticking with Manet, we have his portrait of Berthe Morisot au bouquet de violettes, and there are male nudes as well! (The one below being Antonin Merci&eacute;'s David.) Unchanged: Which isn't to say that I spent all my time in the museum looking at female nudes. Sticking with Manet, we have his portrait of Berthe Morisot au bouquet de violettes, and there are male nudes as well! (The one below being Antonin Merci&eacute;'s David.)
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.impressionism-art.org/ img724.htm"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ manet-berthe- morisot1.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Berthe Morisot au bouquet de violettes" width="400" height="556" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6100" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.impressionism-art.org/ img724.htm"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ manet-berthe- morisot1.jpg" alt="" title="Manet, Berthe Morisot au bouquet de violettes" width="400" height="556" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6100" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.musee-orsay.fr/ en/collections/ works-in-focus/sculpture/ commentaire_id/ david-3186.html?tx_ commentaire_pi1%5BpidLi%5D= 842&amp;tx_commentaire_ pi1%5Bfrom%5D= 729&amp;cHash= 88d9a4bf19"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ mercie-david.gif" alt="" title="Antonin Merci&eacute;, David" width="357" height="514" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6067" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.musee-orsay.fr/ en/collections/ works-in-focus/sculpture/ commentaire_id/ david-3186.html?tx_ commentaire_pi1%5BpidLi%5D= 842&amp;tx_commentaire_ pi1%5Bfrom%5D= 729&amp;cHash= 88d9a4bf19"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ mercie-david.gif" alt="" title="Antonin Merci&eacute;, David" width="357" height="514" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6067" /></a>
Unchanged: Though the most surprising nude of the day was this Acad&eacute;mie d'homme &acirc;g&eacute; nu from a special exhibit of Akseli Gallen-Kallela's work. (Or Axel Gall&eacute;n, as he was known at the time that he painted this picture.) Unchanged: Though the most surprising nude of the day was this Acad&eacute;mie d'homme &acirc;g&eacute; nu from a special exhibit of Akseli Gallen-Kallela's work. (Or Axel Gall&eacute;n, as he was known at the time that he painted this picture.)
Unchanged: <a href="http:// malvasiabianca.org/wp-content/ uploads/2012/ 04/gallen-home- age.png"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-home-age- 595x914.png" alt="" title="Axel Gall&eacute;n, Acad&eacute;mie d&#039;homme &acirc;g&eacute; nu" width="595" height="914" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6072" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// malvasiabianca.org/wp-content/ uploads/2012/ 04/gallen-home- age.png"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-home-age- 595x914.png" alt="" title="Axel Gall&eacute;n, Acad&eacute;mie d&#039;homme &acirc;g&eacute; nu" width="595" height="914" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6072" /></a>
Unchanged: &nbsp; Unchanged: &nbsp;
Unchanged: Anyways: enough nudes, on to video games. The nudes, of course, remind me of character models in video games, and there are plenty of good non-nude character models in the museum: Corot's La jeune femme à la robe rose, Amaury-Duval's Madame de Loynes, Degas's Petite danseuse de quatorze ans (also known as Grande danseuse habillée), Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer's La Sorcière. (Certainly that last one would be very much at home in a video game!) Unchanged: Anyways: enough nudes, on to video games. The nudes, of course, remind me of character models in video games, and there are plenty of good non-nude character models in the museum: Corot's La jeune femme à la robe rose, Amaury-Duval's Madame de Loynes, Degas's Petite danseuse de quatorze ans (also known as Grande danseuse habillée), Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer's La Sorcière. (Certainly that last one would be very much at home in a video game!)
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.amis-arts.com/peintre/ peintres_2/corot/galerie5/ galerie5/62_galerie5_ corot.htm"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ corot-robe-rose.jpg" alt="" title="Corot, La jeune femme à la robe rose" width="459" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6074" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.amis-arts.com/peintre/ peintres_2/corot/galerie5/ galerie5/62_galerie5_ corot.htm"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ corot-robe-rose.jpg" alt="" title="Corot, La jeune femme à la robe rose" width="459" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6074" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// snowce.tumblr.com/ post/15581013718/ eugene-emmanuel- amaury-duval- madame-de-loynes"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ amaury-duval- madame-de-loynes.jpg" alt="" title="Amaury-Duval, Madame de Loynes" width="498" height="600" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6075" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// snowce.tumblr.com/ post/15581013718/ eugene-emmanuel- amaury-duval- madame-de-loynes"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ amaury-duval- madame-de-loynes.jpg" alt="" title="Amaury-Duval, Madame de Loynes" width="498" height="600" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6075" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// triunfo-arciniegas.blogspot.com/ 2012/01/jose- manuel-arango- baila-conmigo.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ degas-petite- danseuse1.jpg" alt="" title="Degas, Petite danseuse de quatorze ans" width="450" height="606" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6103" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// triunfo-arciniegas.blogspot.com/ 2012/01/jose- manuel-arango- baila-conmigo.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ degas-petite- danseuse1.jpg" alt="" title="Degas, Petite danseuse de quatorze ans" width="450" height="606" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6103" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// bourgogne.darkbb.com/t2341- lucien-levy-dhurmer"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ levy-dhurmer- sorciere.jpg" alt="" title="Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer, La Sorcière" width="474" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6080" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// bourgogne.darkbb.com/t2341- lucien-levy-dhurmer"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ levy-dhurmer- sorciere.jpg" alt="" title="Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer, La Sorcière" width="474" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6080" /></a>
Unchanged: But games don't just model people, they model buildings, they model spaces, they model everything that appears within them. Here are some models of buildings, both by Monet, namely his Gare Saint-Lazare and Rouen Cathedral: Unchanged: But games don't just model people, they model buildings, they model spaces, they model everything that appears within them. Here are some models of buildings, both by Monet, namely his Gare Saint-Lazare and Rouen Cathedral:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// smarthistory.khanacademy.org/ france-1848.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ monet-gare-saint-lazare.jpg" alt="" title="Monet, Gare Saint-Lazare" width="512" height="383" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6082" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// smarthistory.khanacademy.org/ france-1848.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ monet-gare-saint-lazare.jpg" alt="" title="Monet, Gare Saint-Lazare" width="512" height="383" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6082" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rouen_ Cathedral_(Monet)"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ monet-rouen-series- 595x552.png" alt="" title="Monet, Rouen Cathedral series" width="595" height="552" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6083" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rouen_ Cathedral_(Monet)"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ monet-rouen-series- 595x552.png" alt="" title="Monet, Rouen Cathedral series" width="595" height="552" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6083" /></a>
Unchanged: In that last example, Monet shows the cathedral in various different lighting scenarios, and that sort of dynamic behavior is a very video-gamey thing to do. Some of the building models had an implicit dynamism of a different nature, however; my favorite example of that was Corot's, Le moulin de Saint-Nicola-lez-Arras: Unchanged: In that last example, Monet shows the cathedral in various different lighting scenarios, and that sort of dynamic behavior is a very video-gamey thing to do. Some of the building models had an implicit dynamism of a different nature, however; my favorite example of that was Corot's, Le moulin de Saint-Nicola-lez-Arras:
Unchanged: <a href="http:// france.jeditoo.com/ NordpasCalais/ arras.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ corot-moulin- de-saint-nicola- lez-arras-595x466.jpg" alt="" title="Corot, Le moulin de Saint-Nicola-lez-Arras" width="595" height="466" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6084" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// france.jeditoo.com/ NordpasCalais/ arras.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ corot-moulin- de-saint-nicola- lez-arras-595x466.jpg" alt="" title="Corot, Le moulin de Saint-Nicola-lez-Arras" width="595" height="466" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6084" /></a>
Unchanged: When looking at this picture, it's impossible not to imagine yourself standing in the woods in the front, walking through them to the building in the back, walking still further to cross the bridge. This isn't a static model in a video game, it's a level that demands exploration. (And, of course, I'm doing this within the Mus&eacute;e d'Orsay, which is itself a space that demands exploration every bit as much as any video game I've ever played!) Unchanged: When looking at this picture, it's impossible not to imagine yourself standing in the woods in the front, walking through them to the building in the back, walking still further to cross the bridge. This isn't a static model in a video game, it's a level that demands exploration. (And, of course, I'm doing this within the Mus&eacute;e d'Orsay, which is itself a space that demands exploration every bit as much as any video game I've ever played!)
Unchanged: &nbsp; Unchanged: &nbsp;
Deleted: So we've moved from models of people to models of buildings to locations to be explored. And, if we combine those, we get paintings with implicit narratives: Henri Regnault's Exécution sans jugement sous les rois maures de Grenade (which, as a bonus, returns us to our video game theme of politically problematic positioning that we led off with, this time with Orientalism instead of male gaze!); Paul Huet's Le gouffre, paysage; George Desvaillières's L'Ascension du Poilu; Gustave Moreau's Galatée. (Male gaze so strong that our lustful onlooker has three eyes! Male gaze was everywhere in this trip: even the <cite>Lion King</cite> posters in the subways were <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ #!/davidcarlton/ status/190064323312369664">full of it</a>.)  Added: So we've moved from models of people to models of buildings to locations to be explored. And, if we combine those, we get paintings with implicit narratives: Henri Regnault's Exécution sans jugement sous les rois maures de Grenade (which, as a bonus, returns us to our video game theme of politically problematic positioning that we led off with, this time with Orientalism instead of male gaze!); Paul Huet's Le gouffre, paysage; George Desvaillières's L'Ascension du Poilu; Gustave Moreau's Galatée. (Male gaze so strong that our lustful onlooker has three eyes! Male gaze was everywhere in this trip: even the <cite>Lion King</cite> posters in the subways were <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ davidcarlton/ status/190064323312369664">full of it</a>.)
Unchanged: <a href="http:// imagesanalyses.univ-paris1.fr/ analysis.php?analysis=44"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ regnault-execution- sans-jugement1.jpg" alt="" title="Henri Regnault, Exécution sans jugement sous les rois maures de Grenade" width="339" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6105" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// imagesanalyses.univ-paris1.fr/ analysis.php?analysis=44"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ regnault-execution- sans-jugement1.jpg" alt="" title="Henri Regnault, Exécution sans jugement sous les rois maures de Grenade" width="339" height="700" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6105" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.linternaute.com/sortir/ magazine/photo/ fontainebleau- un-atelier-grandeur-nature/ le-gouffre-paul- huet.shtml"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ huet-le-gouffre.png" alt="" title="Paul Huet, Le gouffre, paysage" width="537" height="321" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6115" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.linternaute.com/sortir/ magazine/photo/ fontainebleau- un-atelier-grandeur-nature/ le-gouffre-paul- huet.shtml"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ huet-le-gouffre.png" alt="" title="Paul Huet, Le gouffre, paysage" width="537" height="321" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6115" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.georgedesvallieres.com/ actualite2011_ 10_12_orsay_ en.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ desvallieres- ascension.jpg" alt="" title="George Desvaillières, L&#039;Ascension du Poilu" width="283" height="571" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6089" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.georgedesvallieres.com/ actualite2011_ 10_12_orsay_ en.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ desvallieres- ascension.jpg" alt="" title="George Desvaillières, L&#039;Ascension du Poilu" width="283" height="571" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6089" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei: Gustave_Moreau_ -_Galatée.jpg"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ moreau-galatee1.jpg" alt="" title="Gustave Moreau, Galatée" width="465" height="600" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6107" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei: Gustave_Moreau_ -_Galatée.jpg"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ moreau-galatee1.jpg" alt="" title="Gustave Moreau, Galatée" width="465" height="600" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6107" /></a>
Unchanged: I'm sure <a href="http:// livingepic.blogspot.com/">Roger Travis</a> will say it's no coincidence that the paintings that I saw that gave me the strongest video game vibe were illustrations from epics: Adolphe William Bouguereau, Dante et Virgile aux Enfers and two <cite>Kalevala</cite> scenes from the aforementioned Akseli Gallen-Kallela exhibit, namely La Défense du Sampo and La Forgeage du Sampo. That last pair brings us closer to video games in another way: just as games are rarely about a single event, instead presenting a linked chain, here too we have linked scenes. Unchanged: I'm sure <a href="http:// livingepic.blogspot.com/">Roger Travis</a> will say it's no coincidence that the paintings that I saw that gave me the strongest video game vibe were illustrations from epics: Adolphe William Bouguereau, Dante et Virgile aux Enfers and two <cite>Kalevala</cite> scenes from the aforementioned Akseli Gallen-Kallela exhibit, namely La Défense du Sampo and La Forgeage du Sampo. That last pair brings us closer to video games in another way: just as games are rarely about a single event, instead presenting a linked chain, here too we have linked scenes.
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.artgallery2000.com/gallery/ dante-et-virgile-au-enfers- dante-and-virgil-in-hell- by-bouguer-p- 6001.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ bouguereau-dante- virgil-595x740.jpg" alt="" title="Adolphe William Bouguereau, Dante et Virgile aux Enfers" width="595" height="740" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6090" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.artgallery2000.com/gallery/ dante-et-virgile-au-enfers- dante-and-virgil-in-hell- by-bouguer-p- 6001.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ bouguereau-dante- virgil-595x740.jpg" alt="" title="Adolphe William Bouguereau, Dante et Virgile aux Enfers" width="595" height="740" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6090" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// eo.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Dosiero: Gallen-Kallela_ The_defence_ of_the_Sampo.png"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-kallela- defense-du-sampo.png" alt="" title="Akseli Gallen-Kallela, La Défense du Sampo" width="520" height="499" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6091" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// eo.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Dosiero: Gallen-Kallela_ The_defence_ of_the_Sampo.png"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-kallela- defense-du-sampo.png" alt="" title="Akseli Gallen-Kallela, La Défense du Sampo" width="520" height="499" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6091" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.almanart.com/ Akseli-Gallen- Kallela-une-passion.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-kallela- forgeage-du- sampo-595x794.jpg" alt="" title="Akseli Gallen-Kallela, La Forgeage du Sampo" width="595" height="794" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6092" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// www.almanart.com/ Akseli-Gallen- Kallela-une-passion.html"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ gallen-kallela- forgeage-du- sampo-595x794.jpg" alt="" title="Akseli Gallen-Kallela, La Forgeage du Sampo" width="595" height="794" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6092" /></a>
Unchanged: &nbsp; Unchanged: &nbsp;
Unchanged: A couple of years ago, I <a href="http:// malvasiabianca.org/archives/ 2010/08/operas- musicals-and- video-games/">took inspiration from musicals</a> and proposed that narrative video games should present themselves as a sequence of set pieces that are as well-crafted as possible, with just enough connective tissue to let you go from set piece to set piece without being jarring. And my experiences in the Mus&eacute;e d'Orsay gave me a new perspective on that argument: each of those set pieces should have the unity and impact of a painting. There should be a vision, a scene, an interaction at the core of each set piece with the rest unfolding from it. Unchanged: A couple of years ago, I <a href="http:// malvasiabianca.org/archives/ 2010/08/operas- musicals-and- video-games/">took inspiration from musicals</a> and proposed that narrative video games should present themselves as a sequence of set pieces that are as well-crafted as possible, with just enough connective tissue to let you go from set piece to set piece without being jarring. And my experiences in the Mus&eacute;e d'Orsay gave me a new perspective on that argument: each of those set pieces should have the unity and impact of a painting. There should be a vision, a scene, an interaction at the core of each set piece with the rest unfolding from it.
Unchanged: I've been playing <a href="http:// www.bactrian.org/~carlton/ dbcdb/1646/"> <cite>Journey</cite></a> recently; it's a beautiful game, a powerful game, and that power comes in large part from this focus. Imagine a sequence of paintings: your first jump after receiving the scarf, looking up at the broken bridge with a companion, investigating a ruin in a desert, surfing the sand together with your companion through a sequence of gates, going through a blue tunnel and trying to hide from the searchlight of an overhead terror, looking up at a tower to climb, huddling with your companion for warmth against the cold and wind, soaring gloriously through the sky. That's what each level is, and each level does nothing more than what is necessary to bring life to those visions, ending just as you're feeling satisfied with that experience. The levels never drag on; energy that might be devoted to extending the levels or connecting the levels more broadly is instead devoted to making each level more beautiful, to make each level speak to something surprisingly deep inside of you. (Not that they neglect the connective tissue between levels: as with the musical example, connection is necessary, and the tapestries do a beautiful job of that.) Scene after scene in that game emanates from a vision that would absolutely not be out of place in my favorite museum in the world. Unchanged: I've been playing <a href="http:// www.bactrian.org/~carlton/ dbcdb/1646/"> <cite>Journey</cite></a> recently; it's a beautiful game, a powerful game, and that power comes in large part from this focus. Imagine a sequence of paintings: your first jump after receiving the scarf, looking up at the broken bridge with a companion, investigating a ruin in a desert, surfing the sand together with your companion through a sequence of gates, going through a blue tunnel and trying to hide from the searchlight of an overhead terror, looking up at a tower to climb, huddling with your companion for warmth against the cold and wind, soaring gloriously through the sky. That's what each level is, and each level does nothing more than what is necessary to bring life to those visions, ending just as you're feeling satisfied with that experience. The levels never drag on; energy that might be devoted to extending the levels or connecting the levels more broadly is instead devoted to making each level more beautiful, to make each level speak to something surprisingly deep inside of you. (Not that they neglect the connective tissue between levels: as with the musical example, connection is necessary, and the tapestries do a beautiful job of that.) Scene after scene in that game emanates from a vision that would absolutely not be out of place in my favorite museum in the world.
Unchanged: The converse is not, however, true: there were several pictures in that museum that are showing me something that I'm not yet getting from video games. I'll close with Millet's Gleaners and Strindberg's Vague VII, in hopes that one of these years I'll encounter games that hit those parts of my soul. Unchanged: The converse is not, however, true: there were several pictures in that museum that are showing me something that I'm not yet getting from video games. I'll close with Millet's Gleaners and Strindberg's Vague VII, in hopes that one of these years I'll encounter games that hit those parts of my soul.
Unchanged: <a href="http:// deliriumliberty.wordpress.com/ 2011/04/07/the- dukes-illegitimate- daughter-by-haizi/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ millet-gleaners- 595x476.jpg" alt="" title="Millet, The Gleaners" width="595" height="476" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6097" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// deliriumliberty.wordpress.com/ 2011/04/07/the- dukes-illegitimate- daughter-by-haizi/"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ millet-gleaners- 595x476.jpg" alt="" title="Millet, The Gleaners" width="595" height="476" class="aligncenter size-large wp-image-6097" /></a>
Unchanged: <a href="http:// knol.google.com/ k/maryvonne- pellay/strindberg-august/ 370200hmdst2s/142#"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ strindberg-vague-vii.jpg" alt="" title="August Strindberg, Vague VII" width="350" height="561" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6098" /></a> Unchanged: <a href="http:// knol.google.com/ k/maryvonne- pellay/strindberg-august/ 370200hmdst2s/142#"><img src="http://malvasiabianca.org/ wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ strindberg-vague-vii.jpg" alt="" title="August Strindberg, Vague VII" width="350" height="561" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-6098" /></a>

Note: Spaces may be added to comparison text to allow better line wrapping.