You are viewing an old revision of this post, from November 19, 2026 @ 10:00:56. See below for differences between this version and the current revision.
About a year ago, I posted about how intermittent rewards were eating up too much of my day; still an issue, time for an update.
As noted in that post, intermittent rewards are a problem:
The best answer that I currently have to that question is that my brain is far too frequently being pulled by an urge to look up something with short term rewards / intermittent rewards. As a concrete example, I don’t actually think that it’s bad for me to spend some time each day reading Apple News; but it’s also something where I can imagine that I’ll find something new to read if I refresh it or scroll further down or whatever. So I’m doing something random (not planned focus work, something like walking the dogs or going to the bathroom or whatever), and I’ll be listening to a podcast (which is a fine thing to be doing in that context), and then somehow I’ll have my phone out and be reading Apple News or playing Flipflop Solitaire or whatever. And that’s bad for multiple reasons: I’m not paying attention to the podcast (and, if I’m walking the dogs, I’m also not paying attention to either the dogs or the world around me), but also I’m feeding / reinforcing the part of my mind that’s looking for new rewards.
If you’d asked me a few years back, I would have said that the main thing to avoid is apps with algorithmic feeds or other such rewards that are designed to never run out. And it’s true: avoiding that kind of app is step one. But just doing that isn’t enough to stay away from intermitent rewards: even if your main interaction with social media is your chronological Mastodon feed, or if you run across articles through a curated list of RSS feeds that you follow in a news reader, then even though those can run out (and can even run out decently quickly if you curate them tightly enough!), a part of your brain is still hoping that, the next time you open the app, there will be something new. This is still an improvement, because a lot of the time you’ll open the app, and either see nothing new or run out of new stuff after a few minutes, but still, the pull in your brain to open the app remains.
On a similar note, free games that are designed to constantly have you playing one more level (with the hope that you’ll eventually get just frustrated enough to spend money to make it past that frustration) are really bad for curating your attention. Whereas puzzle games like Flipflop Solitaire or the various Conceptis puzzle apps are a big improvement: they present a much more straightforward financial transaction (if you want to play more puzzles, give them more money), and aren’t designed to tweak their difficulty in order to keep you hooked on them. But still, even with a good puzzle game, it’s way too easy when you finish a puzzle to move on to the next puzzle, and then I’ll look up and have spent two hours solving puzzles. Which isn’t the worst thing in the world (those apps have genuinely good puzzles!) but still: not something that I want to just fall into doing. (It’s similar to the “one more turn” problem from Civ games; there’s a reason why I haven’t played any of those for two decades!)
I alluded above to the main context when I would fall into those puzzle apps: I’d be listening to a podcast while not doing anything that actively required me to use my hands, so I’d pull out a puzzle app to give my hands/eyes something to do. (After all, I’ve gone through enough of those puzzles that don’t have to think too hard while playing them, so I can more-or-less follow the podcast while doing them.) And then lots of time would disappear; and also it would turn out that I actually couldn’t follow the podcast all that well, so I’d only have a vague idea of what I was listening to.
With both of these examples, one of the main problems is that I want to fight my brain saying “you could be doing something more if you just looked over here”. Maybe I’d find something interesting if I checked on my RSS reader; maybe I’d feel like I was filling up my time better if I were using my hands / eyes / the puzzle-solving part of my brain as well as using my ears / the narrative part of my brain. But those are both wrong: constaintly looking for something new or trying to use both my ears and my eyes/fingers (on different things!) is not a way to get a rich, rewarding life.
So one thing I’m trying to do is to just be aware of this. Whenever I notice that I actually don’t know what happened in the last five minutes of the podcast that I’m listening to, then I 1) figure out why; 2) either stop the podcast or stop doing whatever else it was; 3) rewind the podcast to whereever I lost the thread.
And it’s the same cause over and over again: I get bothered by not having my hands / eyes doing something. So now my rule is that I shouldn’t be looking at something else on my phone / iPad while listening to podcasts, with the one blessed exception being vocabulary review. (And even there I will sometimes pause the podcast.) I’m not yet a strict unitasker — in my current rules, listening to podcasts while washing dishes or making lunch or walking the dogs is fine — but I’m trying to put in much stronger limits. And I can’t say that I’m actually very good yet at following this rule (especially if I’m a little tired); hopefully with more practice I can start retraining my brain to say “yes, it’s okay to not have my eyes and fingers doing something, even if part of my brain interprets that as being bored and hence bad”.
The second change that I’m trying to make is to be more aware of stuff that I’m regularly spending more time on than I think is a good idea, and putting in more barriers. A few months ago (maybe a year ago, actually) I ended up hiding Flipflop Solitaire and the Conceptis apps on my phone / iPad: it’s not that I think those are bad (I actually think grappling with puzzles is a fine thing to do, and those are really good puzzles), but also if I’ve solved a thousand instances of a given puzzle type, probably I’m not getting so much from the thousand-and-first instance.
That turned out to be really effective: I didn’t actually delete the apps in question, nothing’s preventing me from searching for them and pulling them up again, but in practice it turns out that not seeing them was enough to break the habit. Over the last few weeks, I’m experimenting with moving my phone away from my bedside and powering down my iPad when I take naps, with the hope that that will reduce the amount of time I spend after the nap doing stuff that I don’t feel good about; it’s helped some but not enough, I still need to work on that one.
The third change that I’m trying to do is spend longer stretches of time on stuff that I both value and find it easier to focus on. I’ve been talking about puzzle games above, because they seep into random bits of my life in low-value and even value-destructive ways, but I actually don’t have that problem at all with the sort of console-based video games that I mostly blog about. I play the latter on Monday evenings, Wednesday evenings, and Sunday afternoons, I don’t do anything else while I’m playing them, and I’m good at knowing when it’s time to declare victory on a given game and stop playing it. (It helps that most of those games have a narrative whose conclusion provides a natural stopping point; and it also helps that I’ve got a big backlog of other games that I want to play, so I have an incentive to put down a given game once I’ve hit the end of the narrative.)
So I want more of my life to be like that. I talked about reading books in my earlier post, and I actually have been reading books noticeably more recently. (I finished 12 novels / nonfiction books in September, and 8 in October, which is a step up compared to previous months.) I got an unexpected boost from a friend of mine starting a podcast about the Vorkosigan Saga books; at first, I was just going to listen along (it’s a great series but I finished reading it six years ago, so normally I wouldn’t consider rereading it now), but listening to them talk about it reminded me just how good a series it is. And the books are pretty short and very good at pulling me along, so they allow my brain to be quite happy with sitting down and reading a book for a while without having any urge to do anything else.
Right now, programming is actually being a little annoying in this regard. All my programming is Claude-mediated; and my working habits have me checking in with Claude pretty often, largely because I’ve told it that I want to review every commit. (And sometimes Claude really does need my help, either for product judgment calls or to test out a UI change.) So what ends up happening is that I need to interact with Claude every 3–5 minutes; this is a horrible interval, I can’t do anything rich during that amount of time, so I end up spending time on exactly the sort of thing that I’m trying to wean myself off of. Clearly I need to change my working habits there; Claude is much much more competent than it was a year ago when I came up with rules for Claude, so hopefully I can change things so that Claude only needs to check in with me every 20–30 minutes instead.
The other problem I’m having is that my list of things that I want to spend a finite amount of time on every day is getting a little long. Reading a newspaper and going through a Kanji review app every day are good. I’d stopped most of my puzzle apps, but there were still two-to-four Apple News puzzles that I’d do every day, and there were two-to-five Puzzmo puzzle types that I liked to do every day. But Puzzmo has added a bunch of puzzle types recently, and they’re much more to my taste than their earlier puzzle types, so now it’s turned into five-to-ten puzzles; that’s too much! So: time to cut that down (hopefully the fact that I finally got first place on Flipart will be enough to get me to stop playing that every day…), or maybe even stop doing Puzzmo entirely?
Similarly I don’t think that I want to stop using Apple News, but I do want to find a way to stop reflexively opening it up to fill a few empty seconds. I wonder if there’s a technological solution that will help me with this: e.g. maybe I can remove Apple News and Puzzmo from my default home screen and add in a “Goofing Off” focus mode that adds them back in? We’ll see; I’m not 100% sure if that would be enough of a barrier, but something along those lines might work.
But ultimately I think that my main issue is that I need to be more comfortable with being bored. (Or with having a feeling that my brain labels that way: if I’m listening to a podcast but not doing anything with my fingers, I’m not actually bored, my brain just wants to convince me that I am!) If I can get more comfortable with that, then I suspect that good things will follow.
Post Revisions:
- November 19, 2026 @ 10:00:56 [Current Revision] by David Carlton
- November 19, 2026 @ 10:00:56 by David Carlton
Changes:
There are no differences between the November 19, 2026 @ 10:00:56 revision and the current revision. (Maybe only post meta information was changed.)

Posts